When upgrading your garage door, the choice of materials and paneling styles can make a big difference in the final look and performance. Two popular options you’ll come across are shiplap and tongue and groove. While they may seem similar, they have key differences that affect durability, insulation, and cost. Let’s break it down so you can decide what’s best for your garage door.
What’s the Difference Between Shiplap and Tongue and Groove?
Both shiplap and tongue and groove are designed to create a tight, interlocking fit. However, they achieve this in different ways:
- Shiplap: Features overlapping boards with a small gap (or rabbet) that allows for natural expansion and contraction. This gives shiplap its signature horizontal lines, adding a classic, rustic look to your garage door.
Tongue and Groove: Each board has a “tongue” that fits into the “groove” of the next panel. This provides a seamless connection with no visible gaps, creating a clean and polished appearance. It also creates a better seal against the elements and reduces heat transfer, making it a superior choice for insulation.
Which One is Better for a Garage Door?
- Durability & Weather Protection: Tongue and groove panels lock together more securely, making them better at sealing out moisture, wind, and extreme temperatures. This can be an advantage if your garage is exposed to harsh weather conditions.
- Aesthetic Appeal: If you prefer a more traditional or farmhouse-style look, shiplap is a great choice. If you want a sleek and modern finish, tongue and groove is the way to go.
- Pinch-Proof Designs: Some garage doors offer pinch-proof designs with tongue and groove connections, making them safer by reducing the risk of fingers getting caught between panels.
Installation: There is no difference in how hard the door is to install. The process and speed of installation remain the same for both styles.
Shiplap vs. Tongue and Groove Cost
The cost of your garage door will depend on the type of material and design rather than the panel style itself. Generally, for the same material and design type, shiplap and tongue and groove cost about the same.
Interchangeability of Panels
One important thing to note is that you cannot interchange different garage door panels easily. There are multiple variations of both shiplap and tongue and groove designs, and each manufacturer may have slight differences in dimensions, locking mechanisms, and structural reinforcements. If a panel gets damaged, replacing it with an exact match from the same brand and model is necessary to maintain structural integrity and performance. However if you switch the style they most likely will not fit together, it’s best to consult a professional to make sure no stone is left unturned to ensure your satisfaction the first time!
Insulation and Energy Efficiency
Garage doors play a big role in insulation, and the type of paneling you choose can impact energy efficiency. Shiplap provides moderate insulation but may have small gaps that allow airflow, reducing its effectiveness in extreme weather. Tongue and groove, with its tighter fit, offers better insulation and energy efficiency, which can help maintain a stable temperature inside the garage.
For even better insulation, consider adding a layer of foam insulation behind the wood panels or choosing a composite wood design with built-in insulation.
Customization and Design Options
Both shiplap and tongue and groove garage doors come in various materials, finishes, and stains to complement different architectural styles. You can choose from:
- Wood: Classic and elegant, but requires more maintenance.
- Steel with Wood Overlay: Provides the appearance of wood with added durability and minimal upkeep.
- Composite Materials: Offer a balance of aesthetics and longevity with resistance to weather damage.
Stain and paint choices also allow homeowners to match their garage doors to their home’s exterior. Whether you prefer a natural wood look or a bold modern color, both styles can be customized to fit your aesthetic.
Maintenance and Longevity
Regular maintenance ensures that your garage door lasts for years. Shiplap may require periodic repainting or refinishing, as the overlapping boards can trap dust and moisture over time. Tongue and groove, with its tight fit, is less prone to debris buildup but may need occasional realignment if the wood expands due to weather conditions.
What is the new trend instead of shiplap?
The latest trend replacing shiplap is vertical paneling and board and batten designs. These styles offer a more modern look while still maintaining a timeless appeal.
Why not to use shiplap?
Shiplap can collect dust in its grooves, may be prone to warping in humid conditions, and has become so popular that some homeowners prefer alternative styles for a more unique appearance.
Is shiplap or tongue and groove more expensive?
For the same material and design type, shiplap and tongue and groove cost about the same. The price difference mainly depends on wood type, customization, and labor.
What is better, shiplap or tongue and groove?
Tongue and groove provides a better seal against the elements, making it ideal for insulation and durability. Shiplap, however, offers a more rustic and traditional look. The best choice depends on your desired aesthetic and functional needs.
Which Should You Choose?
If you want a rustic or farmhouse-style garage door with an easy-to-maintain design, shiplap is a great option. If you’re looking for a more refined, weather-resistant finish, tongue and groove is the better choice.
No matter which style you choose, investing in a high-quality garage door enhances curb appeal, increases property value, and improves security. Need help selecting the right garage door for your home? Call us today at (253) 400-3880 to discuss your options!
